The 2009 Television Without Pity Tubey Awards results are in.
Supernatural won Most Welcome New Character (Castiel), and was ranked second in Best Returning Show, Most Underrated Show, Best Badass (Dean), Best Season Finale, Best "WTF" Moment (Sam and Dean discover the Supernatural books and fandom), Best Smackdown in a Non-Reality Show (Sam versus Dean),
The series took the Best Sci-Fi Show award on TV Guide Magazine's 2009 Tubey Awards special categories.
Source: Television Without Pity, TV Guide Magazine.
Disclaimer: WinchesterBros.com and MediaBlvd.com are in no way connected to the awards.