E! Online Watch With Kristin's Tater Tops 2009 voting closes this Tuesday, July 7.
Supernatural is nominated for Best Genre Show, Best Friends (Sam and Dean) and Best Show of Skin (Dean and Anna).
The series is also up for TV Out the Window Moments (Sam and Ruby).
Jeffrey Dean Morgan is up for Best Guest Star for playing dead Denny Duquette on Grey's Anatomy.
To vote, click here.